Loading
Values Exchange

CAN DISCRIMINATION BE A GOOD THING?

Avatar
19 Jul 2014 122 Respondents
56%
+25XPRespond to CaseBoard
David Seedhouse
VX Community
Super Human (23408 XP)
Please login to save to your favourites
CAN DISCRIMINATION BE A GOOD THING?
It is well-known that aboriginal people suffer more sickness and live shorter lives than other groups of Australians. They also find it hard to succeed educationally, to enter university and to have the most desirable careers.

Because of years of negative discrimination, and not being allowed to be part of the 'white system', aboriginal people do not enjoy a 'level playing field' - they start off in a position where they are disadvantaged and have an unequal chance of success.

This has lead to some people to advocate 'positive discrimination' or 'affirmative action' - i.e. in some circumstances giving preferential treatment to aboriginals so as to even things up. For example, allowing a quota of aboriginal medical students each year to enter university even though other students with better qualifications cannot get in.

Here is a short article about 'positive discrimination': riaus.org.au/articles/positive-discrimination-is-it-an-oxymoron/

Here is an article linking racism and depression: www.news.com.au/national/beyondblue-to-launch-a-new-campaign-highlighting-the-link-between-racism...

Here are some relevant statistics: www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/CaSHome.nsf/Home/ISS+Indigenous+statistics+for+schools
What do you think? Is this fair?
It is proposed that positive discrimination is ethical

Key Concepts

Agreement
Disagreement

Gender

Agreement
Disagreement